00:00:17:25 – 00:00:39:19
Unknown
Welcome back, everybody, to this week’s episode of Now We Defend. This week we’re going to be talking a bit about one of the topics that I don’t think our clients really think about when we represent them. And that is something that is very sacred to us. Kind of behind the scenes. And that is the rules of professional conduct.
00:00:39:19 – 00:01:02:14
Unknown
And really what boils down to our rules of ethics as it relates to being attorneys. And I do hope that our clients and even prospective clients out there that might find the topic itself a little bit dry, do try to listen to this, because we’re going to try to work in some stories and some interesting parts that might jazz this up a little, but it’s also important to kind of know the position that your lawyer is in when they’re representing you.
00:01:02:14 – 00:01:19:21
Unknown
Because if you want to have the best type of attorney client relationship, you really do need to understand the position and what your lawyer can and cannot do for you. Because a lot of times we get questions like, you’re my lawyer. Don’t you have to do everything I’m asking you to do? Or I want you to do this?
00:01:19:21 – 00:01:45:22
Unknown
And I think people misunderstand that as being hired as the attorney sometimes doesn’t mean we just do whatever our client asks us to do. And we lie, cheat and steal to get there. That’s actually quite the opposite of what we do. And when we actually sit down with our clients in our initial consults and on our meetings, and we chat with them, and we get to know them and everything, and we recognize that this is a very personal thing, this case for our client.
00:01:45:25 – 00:02:07:02
Unknown
I think there’s also a level of a two way street there that the client also recognizes that we can do so much for them, but only so much. And there are rules and we have to play within certain lanes to do that effectively. And then we also play by a very stringent set of rules. And we’re accountable to the court and to other professionals in our career.
00:02:07:04 – 00:02:22:26
Unknown
And I’ll tell you guys, this is beat into us at law school. Like, this is we actually there’s a whole class in law school about the rules of professional conduct that you have to of course, take, pass, etc., to even become a lawyer. And then it’s also part of, you know, the bar exam and every day in practicing law.
00:02:22:27 – 00:02:51:08
Unknown
I mean, I know in our practice here at our law firm, we’re frequently internally discussing ethics issues and things like that as they come up in cases. So while we understand that our client’s case is very sacred to them and very personal to them. The rules of ethics and the rules of professional conduct are very sacred to us as attorneys, and we need to abide by them at every step of everything we do.
00:02:51:10 – 00:03:15:03
Unknown
Otherwise, we could find ourselves in a position where we can’t even practice law anymore because our law license can be taken away, or any amount of punishments there in up to the possibility of disbarment. So the one question I think a lot of people ask when we’re talking about these rules of ethics is, is why do attorneys even have a separate rule of ethical obligations that they have to abide by?
00:03:15:04 – 00:03:50:04
Unknown
I mean, isn’t the attorney supposed to just be an advocate for the client and just get the client the best result and just be the client’s partner in this? And while a lot of that is true, and a lot of that is what we strive for, the fact that the relationship is sensitive, the fact that it’s personal, and the nature of the representation being sensitive often involves confidential information about our clients, about the circumstances of what happened that our clients disclose to us, and these intensely personal goals that exist for our clients, albeit our intensely personal to us.
00:03:50:09 – 00:04:17:29
Unknown
But the very nature of things being confidential is actually built into these rules of professional conduct. So it’s actually not only a protection of us as the attorneys in our professional licenses, but it’s also a protection of our client’s confidentiality as well. And that’s something I think is lost in the system a little bit, in the sense that we think that these rules are just about lawyers and just about what we do, but it’s actually also about making sure we’re effective and we’re acting properly within those rules for our clients.
00:04:18:08 – 00:04:48:26
Unknown
The rules do balance a lot of different, things that I think they strive to achieve correctly. You know, you have legal conduct and ethical conduct. You know, the balance between those two things, professional responsibility and morality, you know, questions of morality that we have. These are sometimes very personal questions to our personal lives that we have to sometimes balance and struggle with, and many times separate from the representation of our client and the needs that need to be achieved there.
00:04:48:28 – 00:05:06:10
Unknown
I know we’ve talked about in prior episodes how we we don’t hear internalize our clients cases into our personal lives while we work, and we work hard and we work long hours and we try to get a best results for our clients, we do that in a way that we try to keep it separate from our personal lives.
00:05:06:10 – 00:05:36:14
Unknown
I mean, we’ve talked a lot about our personal lives here and our kids and our spouses and our families and our things like that, and we do try to separate that. And frankly, if you can’t do that, you’re probably going to find yourself in a situation where you’re having a hard time as a person and a human being, because we do have to take on and shoulder a lot of very sometimes, uncomfortable or awkward or sometimes even things that we disagree with morally when we, when we handle cases.
00:05:36:16 – 00:05:56:12
Unknown
And then the last thing you know is just the balance of the zealous advocacy and also being unethical in that zealous advocacy. And that’s, that’s also really striking kind of where we’re at here with the professional rules of conduct. And that is we we absolutely need to be zealous advocates for our clients, and we need to guide them correctly and effectively.
00:05:56:13 – 00:06:15:14
Unknown
We need to go to court and argue hard for them and get them good results and fix their cases legally. But we cannot be unethical when we’re doing that. And that is a balance. That is an art, and there’s a lot of lawyers that do it very, very well. And then there’s some that do it in a way that’s a little shady.
00:06:15:14 – 00:06:42:27
Unknown
And those ones do many times find themselves in a bit of legal trouble and possibly have their law license on the line. So, I want to tell everybody, Tim did our outline today. So appreciate Tim doing that. He did excellent job. So I’m going to go to you first, Tim. The big question here I’m going to kind of start with that is the attorneys responsibility to the client ever subordinate or lesser than the attorneys responsibility to the court?
00:06:43:07 – 00:07:08:25
Unknown
To the profession of being an attorney and or to the public. And that’s a three part question, because those are different entities. And how does that break down when it comes to the relationship and the responsibility to our clients? Yeah. So I mean, I guess there’s a couple of different ways to answer this question. I mean, I would say, generally speaking, the attorneys responsibility to a client is almost always subordinate.
00:07:08:25 – 00:07:32:28
Unknown
In fact, it’s probably always subordinate to the responsibilities that we have to the court. Absolutely. And to the profession itself, which is why the rules of ethics exist in the first place. You’re going to hear us say in probably multiple times in this episode that the field that we’re in is a self-regulating, self-regulating field. And what that means is that that the conduct of A is policed by other attorneys.
00:07:32:28 – 00:07:58:26
Unknown
And so these rules are regulated by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, which is made up of attorneys, and they have an enforcement arm, which is the disciplinary board. And they also are enforced. The rules are by the Office of Disciplinary Counsel. And so these are all attorneys, for the most part, who handle the enforcement and make sure that attorneys are playing by the rules.
00:07:59:03 – 00:08:22:04
Unknown
And so the attorneys have an obligation to the profession as well, generally, to be on the lookout for unethical behavior for other professionals, other professionals, and to report that conduct, as we’ll talk about later. Judges obviously are on the lookout for that stuff, too. And it goes both ways. I mean, attorneys also can report misconduct from judges as well.
00:08:22:10 – 00:08:57:27
Unknown
So the fact that it’s a self-policing profession is in some ways unique, because you may not see that in some other professions out there that have similar ethical requirements or very stringent ethical requirements, like the medical field or some other places like that. Those places, sure, it’s probably enforced and police by individuals within the field or who have some knowledge base in the field, but it also a lot of times as police by people who are outside of the field, like administrators who maybe aren’t, you know, they’re not scrubbing up and doing medical procedures.
00:08:58:04 – 00:09:20:06
Unknown
They’ve taken a more administrative role. So it is slightly different in the sense that a lot of times this comes down to attorneys who are actually trial attorneys or in the courtroom practicing with other attorneys and policing other attorneys for ethical and unethical behavior. Yeah. And, you know, Tim, you’re spot on. But this is a big challenge that we shoulder as lawyers, right?
00:09:20:06 – 00:09:48:02
Unknown
Because in a way, we like you said, this is self-regulating. We police ourselves in our profession and we police other attorneys. So we have sometimes been in situations where you almost have to, like, be a little tattletale on another attorney because your ethical obligations require you to do so. In fact, the rules say that if there are an ethical, there is an ethical violation that you’re aware of and it’s affecting the case.
00:09:48:06 – 00:10:05:03
Unknown
You are actually required as a lawyer to report that right. And you as a lawyer can get in trouble if you do not, or you usurp it, or you try to kind of navigate it in a different way, right, right. Acquired to do that. And I’ve always found that to be a little bit uncomfortable. Right. Because, I mean, our colleagues are other lawyers.
00:10:05:03 – 00:10:30:06
Unknown
Many of them are friends of ours. They are at least acquaintances, people that we generally try to maintain, you know, collegial relationships with, and to be professional with. But we also find ourselves sometimes having to, you know, take it another step. Now, I think there’s an art to doing that. Like, I don’t think, you know, the littlest thing that happens, you just run to the D board and just start, you know, telling on everything.
00:10:30:09 – 00:10:49:16
Unknown
But but I think sometimes things get to a certain level that you almost can’t avoid it. Right? Yeah. And I think you’re exactly right. Because, you know, like when I was doing this outline, the first thing that that came to my mind from people on the outside of the profession looking in or maybe clients looking in, they may say, well, why do these rules need to be there?
00:10:49:16 – 00:11:10:04
Unknown
Or why are they so important? How hard is it to just be a good attorney? Well, it’s harder than you think because like you said earlier, the nature of the representation oftentimes does lead us into areas where we may be having to do something that is kind of questionable. And that happens a lot, to be honest with you.
00:11:10:06 – 00:11:29:22
Unknown
I’ve had several cases on the defense side, and as a prosecutor where I’m kind of having to look at something and be like, is this inbounds what we’re doing? Or perhaps the client now reveals a new piece of information to me, and there’s a conflict now where there’s something I wasn’t aware of before, or the client’s asking for certain information.
00:11:29:22 – 00:11:47:20
Unknown
How do I go about disclosing that in an ethical way? What do I do with information that they’ve given me? There are all kinds of ways this comes up. And so you find yourself in ethical quandaries often in this profession, when the attorneys who play fast and loose with it are the ones that that end up getting their license revoked.
00:11:47:20 – 00:12:10:18
Unknown
And if and what you’re talking about about, you know, Dobby or being a tattletale on somebody else, you know, if the violation is substantial enough that my license is on the line, I have no choice. And for me, that’s an easy decision because this is my livelihood. This is how I provide for my family. I will never I will never forfeit my license for the sake of a client.
00:12:10:18 – 00:12:35:21
Unknown
I’m not going to do that because that’s my my livelihood and that’s how I provide for my or another professional or another. Yeah, yeah. Even if they’re a friend. Right. So someone cannot ask me to lie for them in a way that’s unethical now, obviously. Right. We we have confidentiality rules that affect what clients tell us. But I’ve had clients or prospective clients who have straight up asked me to lie for them to the officer or to the court, and I’ve told them, no, I’m not going to do that.
00:12:35:22 – 00:12:58:24
Unknown
Yeah. And I think, you know, good lawyers, we have the ability when those types of things come up, because not obviously all our clients lay people do not know about this unless we explain that to them. So I think there’s a there’s a, a nice way to kind of when a client asks you to do that, to say, hey, listen, here’s why I can’t do that, but here’s maybe how we could handle that instead, where you’re not actually outwardly having to lie to somebody or do something unethical.
00:12:58:26 – 00:13:16:24
Unknown
And we do have to navigate these sometimes very quickly. Right? Right. These situations come up in the courtroom sometimes, and you have to be sharp, know the rules and be able to react in a way that is going to protect your ability to continue being a lawyer. And it gets messy quickly because a lot of these issues come up after you’ve already been hired.
00:13:16:26 – 00:13:35:10
Unknown
And so there’s already been payment for the legal services. There’s already been an agreement for representation. The case may be so far along. And so at this point when there’s an ethical issue that comes up, it has to be addressed quickly and it has to be addressed correctly in order for the representation to have any shot at continuing.
00:13:35:10 – 00:13:53:10
Unknown
And then for us to not run afoul of the disciplinary board or anything like that. And it can create sometimes a conflict in the relationship with the attorney and the client. We’re going to talk actually a little bit about when that becomes irreparable. Right. But a lot of times that’s repairable. You just have to communicate. That’s another thing we’re going to talk about today.
00:13:53:12 – 00:14:12:04
Unknown
You know, communication with our clients and making sure that we’re doing that in a way that doesn’t run afoul of the rules. So we got a lot to get into. So I’m going to pop over here to you. Justin, you are here, by the way. I know you haven’t been on camera. And I think let’s start with just basic standard competency.
00:14:12:06 – 00:14:32:06
Unknown
Right. Like that is actually in the rules of evidence. I think it’s rule 1.1. It’s right in the very beginning to be an attorney. And to do this ethically, you have to at least have a basal level of competency. And this isn’t just I went to law school and I passed the bar exam. Like, you need to be more competent than that in what you’re actually working on.
00:14:32:07 – 00:15:03:06
Unknown
Yes. So competency relates to, you know, in attorneys legal knowledge and skill, you know, takes into consideration how complex and complicated and specialized different areas of the law and cases can be. The lawyers, general experience, lawyers training experience in the field that they’re in.
00:15:03:06 – 00:15:29:05
Unknown
So we’re all in criminal defense, focusing mostly on that for, you know, what we do on a daily basis. Yeah. And we have a requirement to maintain a high level of competency in the actual area that we practice because there’s so many different areas of law. Right? Yeah. Like if someone came to me and again, as Justin said, we do as I think you all know now we defend we do criminal defense work here.
00:15:29:06 – 00:15:49:25
Unknown
That’s what we do. And we all we’re all former prosecutors. So we’ve been in the criminal justice sector of the law our entire careers. Yeah. At least I have I think you guys both have. Right. So with that said, that’s our expertise. We are, I would hope, clearly very competent in that area. But if somebody comes to me and says, hey, tell can you do my divorce for me?
00:15:49:26 – 00:16:09:28
Unknown
Or hey, can you can you write me my my complex will or my trust? I mean, I got plenty of people, guys that I’ll say, hey, here’s the guy, here’s the best guy in York County to go to. Here’s what you should go to. And if you’re a client of mine, you’re going to get the best. But the bottom line is I’m not I’m going to say to them, and I do frequently like, I can’t do that for you.
00:16:10:04 – 00:16:27:15
Unknown
And I say that not because I don’t want to make a fee off of it, because that’d be great, right? But our practice and our ethics are not driven by money. They are driven by our competency to do what we do the best. Yes. And, and that’s why we have this network of referrals that I think, and I know you guys have it too.
00:16:27:15 – 00:16:51:08
Unknown
And we utilize kind of the same people, the same attorneys. We, we frequently are doing that for our clients or for people that just call in if it’s not our what we do. And we do that because we’re protecting ourselves and the client. Absolutely. Know and I think, you know, there are, we’ll say, general practice attorneys out there that kind of delve into many different areas of the law.
00:16:51:10 – 00:17:11:19
Unknown
I would do danger, danger, danger. If you are a general practice attorney and you do everything that’s a problem. And they’re, that worries me when I hear that, you know, I don’t really actually know a lot of people that do that anymore. To be more common, I was going to say not all that common anymore. Like the attorney that you have that writes your will is going to be different from the most likely.
00:17:11:20 – 00:17:29:23
Unknown
I mean, you, in theory could go to one attorney that would write your will, do your divorce. That attorney is going to represent you on a DUI, and then that attorney is also going to, you know, do power of attorney and manage your finances for brokerage or something, but like or draft contracts. But that that is kind of gone the way of the dinosaurs at this point.
00:17:29:25 – 00:17:52:08
Unknown
Yeah. There’s not a lot of general practice attorneys out there anymore. And if if for those of you that are listening, if you are in a situation where you’re with somebody who’s doing that and you’ve side I did a few times, you’re probably doing that because you should be and you should listen to yourself because general practice, it is very, very, very hard to be an expert in every area of the law.
00:17:52:09 – 00:18:11:26
Unknown
Well, that’s what they say. A jack of all trades is a master of none. Right. And and I mean, you know, and not to steal Justin’s thunder, but you’re good. Competency doesn’t just mean that you know a lot about the area you’re practicing in, because the rules don’t really require us to have specialized training to be criminal defense attorneys.
00:18:11:26 – 00:18:31:25
Unknown
There’s and there’s not a place you could go to get special training to be a criminal defense attorney. Most of what you’re going to do or learn is, is going to be done by doing it. Yeah. So we we all went to law school. We all took criminal procedure, criminal law, but we also all took contracts and property law and wills and trusts.
00:18:31:26 – 00:18:53:25
Unknown
And you see that frequently will switch. They’ll do a practicing criminal law and maybe they’ll they’ll go to Wills in estates or something. Your point is that you get the expertise and the clout in a certain area by the practice of being a lawyer in that area. Right. And and the petition. Yeah, exactly. In court. And getting those relationships that are built in your arena competency.
00:18:54:00 – 00:19:25:18
Unknown
It’s not just the level of knowledge I have now, but it’s the expectation of me gathering the knowledge I need along the way. And so the language I quoted in the outline, the rule specifically says that it allows attorneys to represent clients in, quote, wholly novel fields through necessary study. So if I’m going to take a case where I’m going to write somebody, will the expectation for me for competency because I’m not incompetent, just because I’ve never written a will before, I know how to write a will generally.
00:19:25:20 – 00:19:48:21
Unknown
But in order for me to to write that will competently, I have to make sure that I brush up on the law and the requirements, and that I do that according to what those requirements are. So the expectation for competency is that I’m going to do what I need to do to get the knowledge I need to do the thing I’m doing, which is why the general practice attorneys kind of have gone away, because it’s a hassle.
00:19:48:22 – 00:20:08:19
Unknown
Every time I bump into a new area of law, I gotta learn something new. And I think a lot of us just we stick with what we know, what we’re good at, and to branch out and learn something very new, especially later in our careers. It means we have to relearn a lot of things. And that’s that’s just a hard thing for anyone to do.
00:20:08:22 – 00:20:43:14
Unknown
It’s not convenient and it’s not expedient. Yeah. I think, general general practice lawyers, I when I think of that, I think of a guy in like the 1800s that you’d roll up and you’re like wagon and horse and you’d go in there and he’d help you with everything, right? And then I even sometimes think just, you know, about a generation ago or maybe two generations ago, my dad, who was a lawyer when when he was practicing law and he ran a law firm for many years before he was the Da in York County and all that, he did a little bit more general practice than even we’d do.
00:20:43:15 – 00:21:22:14
Unknown
Right. And he would sometimes write a will for people, right? He would sometimes help somebody in a lawsuit civilly. But his focus was criminal law. But I feel it just the the market is saturated for one with lawyers. And it’s really hard to be the best or to be the expert in multiple areas. Right. And while we all, you know, need to make money in this field, and we all need to have clients in order to survive what you is the client or the the lay person or the public should be aware of is it is very, very important when you are seeking out a lawyer in a certain area, do your own homework, like
00:21:22:15 – 00:21:44:22
Unknown
look into that person. With the advent of the internet, which isn’t really the advent anymore because it’s been around forever and AI, now you can look into who you’re talking to and you can see, are they really an expert in this area of the law, or are they somebody that maybe dabbles? And if I’m new and I’m going to a heart surgeon because I need heart surgery, I’m not going to the guy that dabbles, I’m going to the guy that’s going to like, save my life.
00:21:44:22 – 00:22:03:06
Unknown
Right? And it’s the same thing with the law. You really got to go to the people that know what they’re doing. I know, I mean, I’m sure you guys do it too. I go to other lawyers to help me with legal things. For instance, I never I didn’t write my own will. I had another lawyer do that because I knew that I needed it to be, you know, well written.
00:22:03:06 – 00:22:17:14
Unknown
I needed it to uphold in court. And I wanted it to be correct. And I did my homework. And I mean, obviously have relationships with people. So I know who’s who. And were actually my wife and I are talking about rewriting our wills. And we were just talking the other night about like, who we’re going to go see for that.
00:22:17:15 – 00:22:34:08
Unknown
Yeah, I know you don’t do that too. Yeah, we probably will. Justin I don’t have a will. We should all do that. We should make that a law firm thing. We all need to get our wills. Especially. You don’t have a will. I have one, but it’s really old, like, I. I had one that I got done when I was in the military, but like, I mean, here’s something to do.
00:22:34:09 – 00:22:49:22
Unknown
I, I, I have a guy who. Right. I’m gonna contact him. I’m not gonna say his name, but I’m gonna. Maybe we can. I’ll tell him I got all three of my lawyers here. We all need wills. Hook us up. That we’ve probably like we’ve been we would go through for it normally, but we just haven’t done it.
00:22:49:22 – 00:23:09:06
Unknown
And that’s just because we’ve been dragging our feet. But, I mean, it is obviously important for you to make sure that you’re, you’re, you know, you’ve got that plan. Yeah. You know, you said something earlier about like the 1800s, which I think is exactly like it’s intuitive because like general practice attorneys used to be more common in years and, and eras past.
00:23:09:07 – 00:23:29:26
Unknown
It’s like the country lawyer. Yeah. Right now, though, the law has gotten much more complicated. Oh, yeah. And that’s really why the general practice attorneys kind of have become a little bit more few and far between. Because no matter what area of law you practice, we’re in an age where, especially in this country, I mean, we’ve had 250 years of case law developments in pretty much every area of law at this point.
00:23:29:27 – 00:23:53:02
Unknown
And even in the new emerging sectors of law, there’s interaction with all kinds of other well-established areas of law. For me to just jump into a brand new area right now, I would have to really get get on track with everything that’s happened up to this point. And that that’s a tall order to do. I mean, we don’t have the time when we’re representing clients who want results.
00:23:53:02 – 00:24:27:00
Unknown
Now to to say, well, hold on, hold the phone. Way to tick. I need to go and study Lexis for the next, you know, three months. So that I’m familiar with the procedure on this. And I think that’s why it’s so difficult, because it’s just more complicated now than it ever was before. Yeah, yeah. And guys, I, I do want to say to our clients, the public, I feel very fortunate and thankful that we are able to have enough business in the criminal field that we don’t have to go the way of trying to be some sort of general practitioner, an expert of none.
00:24:27:21 – 00:24:46:15
Unknown
And I hope that the other attorneys out there, you know, especially local ones that we’re friends with, and I think a lot of them do this very well. They’ve become very good at their craft. Yeah. And their area that they’re able to maintain their business and their income in that area. And it’s made them better lawyers in that area for it.
00:24:46:16 – 00:25:01:20
Unknown
Absolutely. And I hope it’s always like that here at our law firm. I think it will be. But, you know, you never know. Things always change. So I do want to move on, though, from this point, I want to talk a little bit about the scope of representation. Right. So this is like when the client comes in, we sit with them, we talk about it.
00:25:01:20 – 00:25:23:24
Unknown
And this kind of gets to what we were just talking about. Like what are we actually representing you on. Yeah. But the scope is also not just what we’re representing you on. It’s how we can do it, you know, and and what we can do and what plays we can make and can’t make. So, Justin, I’m going to come back over to you to talk a little bit about that and, how that relates to maybe what our client’s views are on things as well.
00:25:23:25 – 00:25:40:19
Unknown
Absolutely. So, basically with scope, I’ll start, you know, when we meet with people, I know you guys do it. I do it after we meet with them, discuss our case, what they’re looking for, you know, are we going to represent them at a preliminary hearing? Are we going to represent them in a PFA, or are we going to represent them?
00:25:41:09 – 00:26:10:26
Unknown
In the Court of Common Pleas? All of those things are different. And I always try to define exactly where the case is going, what hearings or proceedings that I’m going to be representing a person for people who have multiple cases. And we lay that out in our fee agreement letters, exactly what we’re representing them on. And I think that’s, you know, very important to have something in writing, laying that out there.
00:26:11:21 – 00:26:38:10
Unknown
Not only for them, but to, again, protect ourselves. Yeah. It’s important. And that is important to. And like, every once in a while, you get into, like, a fee dispute question with a client. I think this happens very infrequently, but it does happen sometimes. And this is why as lawyers, we always do a written fee agreement, because if it’s in writing and we all read it and we all understood it and we talked about it and we and it’s clear and we signed it.
00:26:38:12 – 00:26:57:04
Unknown
Yeah. When there’s questions later we can go back to that document. And maybe I’m right, maybe you’re right. But we can look at it and say, okay, what did we actually both agree to? And, and this, this is why, you know, we do this for a lot of reasons legally. But this is the main reason, I think, for the client relationship that we do that.
00:26:57:12 – 00:27:15:16
Unknown
And I like to be very kind of succinct but also clear in these letters. Right. And I also follow it up with I don’t hand a client a letter and say sign it. I mean, we talk about it. Yeah. You know, we kind of formulate it together in a way. Absolutely. And then that way again, if there’s a conflict later, we can refer back to a written document that we all agreed on.
00:27:15:18 – 00:27:39:06
Unknown
Yep. You know. Absolutely. And, so going off of that, the scope of representation must be clearly defined and limited. Which we just talked about, we can’t counsel people on, you know, going out and doing unlawful acts or committing criminal acts. I also kind of in this one would include some questions or not. Some questions.
00:27:39:12 – 00:27:59:11
Unknown
A lot of questions I got when prepping witnesses and victims and things in the district attorney’s office, as well as, you know, clients now on defense. Some of these some people want the attorney to tell them what to say. And how do I or what should I say in my testimony? Like, give them a script on that.
00:27:59:18 – 00:28:18:24
Unknown
And that’s something I think that’s a big misconception for people that don’t practice law. Like we can’t tell you what to say. We can’t, you know, give you a script. We can advise you on what not to say. We can invite you on. Maybe things you can go do in the meantime to better your chances of a good result.
00:28:19:07 – 00:28:39:22
Unknown
But we can’t, again tell you to go out and commit a legal acts or, commit bank fraud or, you know, things like that. So and again, to your point of like a client asking you, like, tell me what to say. Like, yeah, first of all, guys that never plays well in court. You don’t want to sit there and read off of a script and like you’re in a play or something in court.
00:28:39:22 – 00:28:57:20
Unknown
It just. It looks dumb. It looks it looks like you’re trying to avoid certain topics. It doesn’t look natural. It’s not a good way to conduct yourself. What I usually do when clients ask me like, what exactly should I say? I kind of have a few rules. I go by one if you’re going to testify, if you’re testifying under oath, right.
00:28:57:20 – 00:29:16:15
Unknown
Because sometimes clients speak in court and they’re not under oath, right. Maybe like a sentencing hearing or something like that. But most of the time, if you’re defendant, your criminal client is going to testify in court. They’re doing so under oath. They’re going to be doing so under oath. So in that scenario, rule number one is when you’re under oath, dude, you got to tell the truth.
00:29:16:16 – 00:29:31:16
Unknown
Yeah. Like if you’re going to get on the stand, you’re getting on the stand and you’re knowing from me that you are absolutely doing that and you’re telling the truth. Yeah. Because if you’re not, you’re perjuring yourself and your committing a crime, and then I am permitting you to do an unlawful act. Yeah. And that’s one thing too.
00:29:31:18 – 00:29:59:14
Unknown
You know, if I was just having this conversation with the friend recently about, you know, is there a time where you don’t want to know what your client did? And I was like, it’s not that often, at least for me, but I’ve definitely had conversations with people and consoles where they start going into something and I’m like, actually, I don’t want to know because down the road, if they’re going to testify or present testimony and again, they’re going to be under oath.
00:29:59:16 – 00:30:04:22
Unknown
It’s kind of a, I think a, a gray area.
00:30:04:25 – 00:30:25:17
Unknown
I don’t know, basically where I’m going with that is if they get on the stand and I know they’re lying, I have to bring that up to the court. Yeah. You’re actually required by these rules. You have special conduct to have candor to the court and to write a known illegal falsehood. Yes. So I hear you on that.
00:30:25:25 – 00:30:43:00
Unknown
But there’s always the blow off valve in a criminal case, which we have this protection. Guys, as a criminal defendant, you do not have to testify in your own case. You have a right to remain silent. And when you have a client who wants to get up there and wants you to walk them through how they’re going to lie through everything.
00:30:43:02 – 00:31:02:22
Unknown
My, again, my number one rule is if you’re going to testify, you got to tell the truth, because I’m not putting my law license online. And frankly, you could get charged with additional crimes like perjury if you lie and it’s known. So what I always tell them is, what’s probably better to do is let’s argue these angles, but not have you testify to these angles.
00:31:02:24 – 00:31:20:25
Unknown
Right. Maybe we can use some other pieces of evidence to make these arguments. But you’re not getting up there and lying through your teeth, which, by the way, many times convicts clients. They end up losing because they decided to do that. Yeah. So that’s another reason not to do it. But yeah, that’s a big one. You know, not engaging in unlawful conduct.
00:31:21:25 – 00:31:39:18
Unknown
My, my dad used to tell me, and I remember this story from him when he was, when I was a kid, and he was a practicing lawyer, and he he had a law office, much like our law office here, you know, down in New York City. It was a beautiful building he was in. And he used to always tell me two things kind of worried him as a lawyer.
00:31:39:20 – 00:31:58:25
Unknown
One, somebody would come in that had some vendetta against him and hide a bag of crack cocaine behind his toilet, and then go run down to the police and say, hey, Kearney’s dealing cocaine. He hides it behind his toilet. And then the police would show up and there was the cocaine. So he would actually, on occasion, check behind his toilet.
00:31:58:27 – 00:32:24:15
Unknown
So I just think about that sometimes and how, you know, clients can sometimes put us in very precarious situations. Luckily, it never happened. The second thing and more kind of to reality, I think, is what if you have a client come in and say, hey, I, I just committed assault or murder. I just shot a guy and here’s the gun, and they slap it on the table in front of you.
00:32:24:19 – 00:32:47:24
Unknown
I feel like that’s a there are cases involving this. Oh, yeah, I know. Yeah, yeah. And I want to talk about that. I want to unpack that a little bit. So let’s talk about that. So if that happens as a lawyer you’ve got some ethical quandaries there that you’ve got to deal with. You know you’ve got some things that you got to think about because for one, and here’s what I here’s my answer to this question I want to know what your guys take is.
00:32:47:24 – 00:33:11:00
Unknown
But if you store or take that firearm and keep it, you’re harboring evidence in a murder or in a assault, and you’re clearly not allowed to do that because you’re hurt. You’re helping propagate the crime. Yes. Or or kind of destroying or keeping away evidence of that crime. So you can’t do that. So, I mean, so what do you do?
00:33:11:02 – 00:33:26:03
Unknown
You obviously don’t take it, but do you then have an obligation to now actually turn it over to police if they give it to you? I mean, what where does that go? What do you guys think? Well, I mean, you would never you would never take it. I mean, you wouldn’t take the case laws. So. But what do you say to the client?
00:33:26:03 – 00:33:47:26
Unknown
He slaps it on the table. What do you say? I mean, well, and I’m not. I’m not accepting that. Yeah, yeah, we we can’t take that. We can’t accept that. And you explain to him why. And. Yeah. And and you can tell them like you need, you’re going to need to take that. And like I, I would not recommend that you destroy it or that you hide it, but I can’t advise them to commit a crime and destroy them.
00:33:47:27 – 00:34:08:19
Unknown
You can’t you can’t advise them to tamper with the evidence, but you would just tell them, I mean, unless there is a valid warrant or something that comes and they’re looking for it or they’re going to seize it, at that point, you have no obligation to just affirmatively go and hand that to the police. But I cannot take that and store it for you or hide it or something like that.
00:34:08:21 – 00:34:29:15
Unknown
There are where it gets really muddy is what do you do with information that a client gives to you? Like there is a case that I remember involving someone who, he had the location of the body. The attorney did, and I think the attorney actually went to the location and actually confirmed that the body was there. Mistake.
00:34:29:21 – 00:34:48:14
Unknown
Yeah. You don’t do that if you have location on where the if you have information where the body is in a murder case, you’re not going because the moment you go there and confirm you’re actually you’re a witness. You’re a witness, you’ve become a witness. You force yourself to become a witness. You’re now investigating a crime, and you’re essentially doing what the police were supposed to be doing.
00:34:48:20 – 00:35:08:04
Unknown
And you’re kind of making yourself in a situation where you can’t even represent the guy anymore. Yeah. You know, I mean, a guy could tell you information, I think as a lawyer, like in the in that example, Tim, a guy says, hey, I know where the body is at. I buried it here. My thought on that is, I don’t have to.
00:35:08:04 – 00:35:32:07
Unknown
I’m not telling that to anybody. I’m also not going there. Yeah. You know, well, and I think the the thing that got that lawyer into trouble, if I remember the facts of the case correctly, are that he went there, that he, he either uncovered or unearthed the body somehow and then covered it back up so that he basically made it like it was, left it in the condition that it was when he found it, which I think is is what partly got him into trouble.
00:35:32:07 – 00:35:52:19
Unknown
Now I if I remember and and this is really taxing, that could be like accessory to murder. That’s taxing my memory a little bit, but I don’t I don’t think the court had a problem with the fact that he confirmed that the information was correct. I think the problem that they had was that he interacted with the body and that that essentially made him a witness.
00:35:52:19 – 00:36:10:21
Unknown
Now where and then to, like we said, to then cover the body up again or something is to is to tamper with evidence at that. Did he ultimately this attorney did did they disclose it after the fact? It came out. It came out that he that he knew or that he had he had been there and I forgot, interacted with the body.
00:36:10:22 – 00:36:37:06
Unknown
Yeah. Because that’s and I forget now all the facts of that case. But that’s the kind of stuff that you get into as an attorney where you know, you, you’re given a piece of information and then you go out and do your due diligence to just confirm that it’s correct and you do the wrong things. When you’re when you’re doing all of that, the far better play, I think, is you put that piece of information in the pocket and then with the, with the, with the client’s consent.
00:36:37:06 – 00:37:01:01
Unknown
That can be a bargaining chip that you use with investigators. And if you know, if they’re already on to him and he’s already being charged, if he agrees to give up that location in exchange for consideration, now you have a client who’s willing to give that information to police. You’re not in a position where you’re just taking that information, which should be confidential, and then relaying it to police without your client’s knowledge, which violates confidentiality.
00:37:01:02 – 00:37:22:18
Unknown
Yeah. And you guys have all heard of cases, usually high profile cases where the location of the body, as Tim said, is sometimes a bargaining chip in. And there is consideration duly given many times for that because it it does allow the family to recover their loved ones body to, you know, go through the proper services to do it.
00:37:22:19 – 00:37:44:10
Unknown
And obviously this would be in like a guilty plea situation if you’re giving up the body. But, yeah, I mean, there’s there’s ways that you can kind of as crass as it is to use that as a, as a chip to ultimately get consideration for your client while also helping the loved ones family get some closure. Yeah, absolutely.
00:37:44:13 – 00:38:08:25
Unknown
So absolutely. Yeah. So it comes to scope of representation to one of the big things that I’ve had that that I’ve seen a lot in private practice, especially when you form that relationship with somebody as a attorney and a client. The big issue that that I run into, and I don’t know how you guys, if you’ve seen this, but I think a lot of times the clients have the mistaken impression that the attorneys just this Swiss army knife.
00:38:08:27 – 00:38:26:00
Unknown
And it does go back to what we talked about with competency earlier and having an area of practice that you stick in and, and the lane that you’re in, you stay there. A lot of times people they hire you for like a criminal case, but they’re going to ask you all these other questions that have nothing to do with the representation.
00:38:26:03 – 00:38:41:22
Unknown
And they just kind of expect that you’re going to give them answers and advise them and talk with them through some of that stuff. And I have several clients now that I’m going through this, where it’s like, this is outside the scope of what you hired me for. Yeah. And I’m not just like a utility piece like that.
00:38:41:22 – 00:38:59:14
Unknown
You can that you can pull out another tool because you hired me for this thing, and now you expect that I’m going to go to work on something else for you? That’s not how this works. Yeah. That’s why you’re finding the scope is so important, right? Right. You’re the knife. You’re not the screwdriver and the wrench and the magnifying glass and everything else in there.
00:38:59:14 – 00:39:19:04
Unknown
But yeah, you’re right. Like that actually does sometimes create a little bit of an awkward situation because the person thinks like, oh, you’re my lawyer. You’re just my my resource for everything legal, right? Yeah. Hey, I got this thing in the mail, and they they I want you to spend an hour reviewing it, figuring out what it is like, and there’s a taxable way to handle that.
00:39:19:04 – 00:39:32:08
Unknown
And I think we’re pretty good at that here. But the way I do it is I kind of say. Yeah, I mean, if you want to send me something, I’m happy to look at it real quick. But then I quickly turn that around and say, okay, this is outside my wheelhouse. Yeah, but I think I know a guy who might be able to help you with this.
00:39:32:08 – 00:40:06:27
Unknown
Yeah, right. That’s how I. This happens actually a lot in, where we represent kids in school, situations where, say, they got in trouble at school, they had marijuana at school, they were vaping. At school, they exchanged nude images with another student or something like that, and they are legally being charged with something. But then the school is actually taking separate, completely separate school education based action, you know, on their ability to be a student there at the school, whether they might be suspended, whether they might be disciplined in some other way or even expelled.
00:40:07:03 – 00:40:24:22
Unknown
And what I’ve always done in that situation is I got a guy and it’s the guy that I know, and he does well in this area and he’s sharp. He’s he’s the person who I’d want if it was my kid. Right. And I send him the name and the number and it’s a quick ten minute conversation and they go there and I know they’re going to be well taken care of.
00:40:25:06 – 00:40:48:20
Unknown
And, you know, they get a good result. Yeah. So, but I think as, as attorneys like when those things come up, we have to at least address them in a sense that we should talk to our client about it, but we don’t have to take on that on top of everything else that we’re already doing. So just being tactful about that, I want to move on to the one that I think is most near and dear to me in the rules, and that is communication.
00:40:48:22 – 00:41:18:15
Unknown
And I think this is important to to all of us here. And I, I think we do this in a way at our law firm that might be quite different from how other attorneys handle this communication, communication, communication. It literally in my opinion, it wins cases. It leaves you with satisfied clients. It leaves you with people who felt like they were heard and that they were partners with you in this, and they weren’t just being dictated to the whole time about this, that and the other thing and what they need to do and listen to, etc..
00:41:18:18 – 00:41:37:27
Unknown
And if you communicate with your client and you do it frequently, you do it efficiently and you do it well, meaning thoroughly, you’re going to find yourself in a situation that even if you got a result that was tough to swallow, might have been a big case. It might have been a hard, you know, facts to deal with.
00:41:38:01 – 00:41:55:03
Unknown
But if you were honest and communicative with your client about it throughout the entire process, you’re going to find at the end your client is pleased because not only were they informed, they saw what was coming, they didn’t get surprised, and they were a partner with you in helping you get to a mitigated fixed result in the case.
00:41:55:14 – 00:42:20:18
Unknown
And I do think this is one that gets a lot of lawyers into hot water, because it’s probably the number one thing that clients complain about when they file complaints or lawsuits or whatever against their against their, their attorney is the communication. I even tell my clients in the meeting, the number one, the very first consul. Communication is the most important thing to me about our relationship.
00:42:20:25 – 00:42:42:07
Unknown
For instance, there are going to be points in this case where I am engaging closely in a regularly with prosecutors and district attorneys offices and things like that, and even the courts. And I need to be prompt in my communication with those other professionals. I need to be correct. I need to be accurate and thorough, and the only way I can do that is if I’m having good, thorough engagement with you.
00:42:42:08 – 00:43:06:12
Unknown
My client and I sometimes even say it like this I have a requirement if I’m going to agree to represent you, and that is that you and I have a good level of communication, and I go sometimes as far as to say I expect same day communication from my clients. And it’s a two way street. If you call me, if you have questions, I’m going to communicate with you in the same day.
00:43:06:12 – 00:43:24:10
Unknown
I might call you back in the evening after I’m done. Court. And it doesn’t have to be same day, but this is kind of a base smart or base level that I think if you start there and things have to happen or things are a little different, it’s respected and it’s understood. So this communication piece is really, really important.
00:43:24:13 – 00:43:46:27
Unknown
And the client has an absolute right to know what is going on with their case to be communicated well with. That’s why it’s in the rules of professional conduct, because we are required to do that as lawyers. And there are so many attorneys that don’t do this well, and they find themselves getting complained about or getting in legal hot water because they haven’t been doing it.
00:43:46:27 – 00:44:09:19
Unknown
And, I just think it’s one of the most important things, like other things could possibly go a little south, maybe not be perfect, but if you can be really hot and, you know, mainly focused on communication, you really can’t go wrong with the rest of it. So all right, so I kind of did communication. So now we’re going to move on to confidentiality.
00:44:09:27 – 00:44:29:00
Unknown
So confidentiality is everyone knows what that means. You know lawyers we have an attorney client privilege with our clients. Justin, what does that. What does that mean? Like, okay, what is attorney client privilege? Because there’s all sorts of privileges out there. There’s doctor patient privilege. There is, priest religious privilege. I don’t know what that’s called.
00:44:29:00 – 00:44:55:03
Unknown
Exactly. There’s all sorts of professional privileges. Yeah, but we’re not here to talk about those. We’re here to talk about the attorney client privilege. What are the limits to that? And what does that mean? Yep. So the way I think about confidentiality, they’re turning client privilege just generally, you know, when I’m meeting with somebody and, you know, I’m their attorney and they’re telling me things, I just kind of start anything you well, anything that they tell me is confidential.
00:44:55:03 – 00:45:24:08
Unknown
And then you kind of go from there as far as you know, what are the exceptions? Are there things that aren’t confidential? One of the things that I try to tell people the most is if we have a conversation and what you tell me falls under attorney client privilege and confidentiality, if you then go and blab about it to someone else, or, you know, I’m on the phone with you and you have me on speaker and there’s someone else there, it’s no longer confidential.
00:45:24:27 – 00:45:48:28
Unknown
And so we do have a duty of candor towards the court or in court. So we can’t make, you know, false statements or fail to correct false statements made to the court like we were just talking about earlier. We can’t fail to disclose, binding legal authority to the court, and we cannot offer evidence that we know is false.
00:45:48:28 – 00:46:10:13
Unknown
Again, going back to what we talked about a little bit earlier. Yeah. So but the candor to the court is extremely important. We have to honor it. We have to be correct about the three main things that you just said. They’re correcting false statements, not making false statements, failing to disclose authority, and, offering evidence that is false.
00:46:10:13 – 00:46:31:12
Unknown
It’s four things. But at the same time, just because we know something that our client told us doesn’t mean we have to disclose that that is different than, you know, not making false statements. Yes. Okay. We can not talk about confidential communications that we’ve had with our clients. Right? We do that. Right. And there are a lot of ways this comes up.
00:46:31:19 – 00:46:51:09
Unknown
For instance, I’ve had situations where the district attorney’s office has miscalculated my client’s range of sentence. Yeah, right. Because they, for whatever reason, made a mistake or didn’t find certain things in their record. This doesn’t happen a lot because they are actually pretty damn good at this. But I mean, we all worked in that office. We know how good they are.
00:46:51:09 – 00:47:14:00
Unknown
But mistakes are sometimes made, and I don’t have a duty to go over there and start busting down their door and being like, hey guys, you missed this one crime on my client’s criminal record, and therefore his charges and his sentence should be higher. Yeah, I would never do that. But what you can’t do is you can’t go into court and say to the judge, this isn’t on the record, but what you can do is not talk about it.
00:47:14:01 – 00:47:38:04
Unknown
Yeah, okay. You don’t have to bring that up. Correct. So I mean, that’s that’s kind of like an example of where this sometimes gets a little, I don’t know, uncomfortable. Yeah. But we also have that duty of confidentiality to our client. Yeah. You know, I think a lot of situations that it comes up where, you know, we know things or are aware of things that our clients have told us that, again, are covered under the attorney client privilege.
00:47:38:27 – 00:47:54:20
Unknown
And you kind of have to walk a fine line, I think, because a lot of what we do, especially here, as we talked about in a lot of episodes, you know, we at least here in New York County, have a pretty good relationship with all of the, attorneys in the district attorney’s office. Police officers.
00:47:54:20 – 00:48:25:26
Unknown
And part of that is, you know, talking to them about cases and our clients. And, there are definitely situations where I’d love to maybe tell a little bit more to maybe get a little bit of a better result. But at the same time, you know, we’re we’re bound by the rules of confidentiality and we can’t. Now, if I talk to my client and say, hey, I don’t have to go and tell them this, but it could potentially help you out if they give me the.
00:48:25:26 – 00:48:48:22
Unknown
Okay, that’s a different story. Yeah, but I’ve definitely had a couple situations where, you know, the client that I had just really wanted me to give up absolutely nothing, and they were kind of worse off for it. But, you know, we have to listen to our clients when it comes to some of that stuff. And then when you want to, if you want to get into the stuff that we, I guess have to reveal.
00:48:48:24 – 00:49:10:03
Unknown
Yeah, I do, and I actually, Tim, I want to pop over to you for this. So obviously the attorney client privilege, it’s pretty far reaching. It is. It’s sacred. And our clients need to and have every right to trust that their attorney is going to honor it and not disclose things that they shouldn’t be disclosing that could harm them.
00:49:10:08 – 00:49:29:03
Unknown
But to Justin’s point, you brought up a good point, and I was actually going to click over and talk about this, but you you beat me to it, which was good. Strategically, sometimes it’s important to talk about certain things. Right. And you want to share certain pieces of information, but you always have to check and talk to the client and explain to them, like why you want to do that and how it could benefit them.
00:49:29:03 – 00:49:48:14
Unknown
And most of the time, with people with half a brain, once they see the strategic move there, they’re going to go, oh yeah, that makes sense. Let’s do that. If you have certain clients that are like, no, I don’t want to share anything. Okay, that’s fine too. Well, we’ll attack the case differently then, you know. But we’re not going to go that route so we can do that.
00:49:48:14 – 00:50:12:08
Unknown
But there are certain things that when our clients say them to us or that we have to actually, we’re bound to reveal them. It’s very, very limited. But I want to tell us what they are just so people know. Yeah. I mean, we have to disclose information to prevent our clients from committing criminal acts. We have to we have to disclose information that would prevent death or substantial bodily injury.
00:50:12:10 – 00:50:47:04
Unknown
We also have to, we also have to present information if there is, if there’s like a fraudulent act or something like that, that, that we were used for. Right. We have to reveal that and we have to disclose how our services were used to further that fraud or commit that crime. And then the last one is one that mostly is for attorneys themselves, is that we can disclose information when it comes to seeking legal advice for compliance with these rules.
00:50:47:10 – 00:51:10:10
Unknown
So if we’re in a legal like an ethical situation and we want to seek advice for how to handle that situation ethically, we are allowed to reveal information in that context to get either a ruling or something from the disciplinary board, or to get advice from an ethics attorney or someone who’s going to advise us of how we would navigate that ethical question.
00:51:10:13 – 00:51:30:03
Unknown
Yeah. So you did say one thing there that I want to just touch on. We are required to reveal information to prevent our client from committing a criminal act. So I want to clarify this because every one of our clients, well, not everyone, but a lot of our clients come to us and say, I’ve committed a criminal act.
00:51:30:03 – 00:52:05:28
Unknown
That’s why I need a criminal defense lawyer. You okay? That is different than I am now going to go out and commit another criminal act that could harm somebody or do something, you know, illegal. Obviously, we don’t have to disclose you telling us that I did this in the past, this criminal act. What Tim is talking about there is if you are disclosing to us that you were going to go out and, like, harm someone or commit future criminal acts against others, those are the types of things that we have to potentially disclose and likely, depending on the nature of it, actually do disclose.
00:52:06:01 – 00:52:20:28
Unknown
So obviously don’t go into your lawyer and be like, hey, I’m going to go break the law and here’s how I’m going to do it. What do you think? Is that a good way to do it? That would be stupid. To do and you shouldn’t do that. And that’s not what lawyers are here for. We’re here to help you kind of after the fact.
00:52:20:28 – 00:52:37:09
Unknown
We’re here to help you and advise you on what not to do in the future to protect yourself. But I just wanted to clarify that because, I mean, all we represent is people who commit, you know, some criminal acts usually. So that’s what we do in criminal defense. And we don’t have to disclose what our clients tell us about what they did.
00:52:37:09 – 00:53:03:03
Unknown
That is that is the attorney client privilege and the beauty of it to its very core. I do want to tell one story here. This happened to me in my very first trial that I tried as a defense attorney after I left the DA’s office. This was probably back in like 2012. So I as a as a day when I was a prosecutor, I was in the Major Crimes Unit where I prosecuted.
00:53:03:03 – 00:53:23:19
Unknown
I don’t even know how many trials, like big time stuff, like tons of trials, etc. but when you flip over to the other side and you know, you end up doing criminal defense, you’re still doing the same type of trials, but you’re on the other side, right? So your your arguments are a little different. The rules of evidence are still the same, the rules of professional conduct are still the same, etc..
00:53:23:21 – 00:53:41:13
Unknown
And I was actually handed this case by my former boss in the case that he had and wanted me to try just to kind of just get right back into the courtroom trying cases. And I went in there, it was a it was a DUI case, and it ended up being what amounted to about a two day trial.
00:53:41:20 – 00:54:00:27
Unknown
And on day one, we picked a jury, we opened, and we started presenting evidence. And, the Commonwealth, of course, was presenting, I was presenting, we kind of did all that. But one of the pieces of evidence that I presented, because my client provided me with it, and I reviewed it, and it looked legitimate to me.
00:54:00:27 – 00:54:27:04
Unknown
And we were there at the day of trial. And it was something that specifically refuted the timeline of the prosecution. And I presented it to my client who was testifying on the stand, and I had him testify to it and the timeline that it called for, and why this was in a situation where he couldn’t have been DUI at the time because, of this timeline of where he was at and what he was doing, it was kind of like a quasi alibi thing, but it wasn’t exactly.
00:54:27:04 – 00:54:57:01
Unknown
And it was an actual document from a, a shop that had a timestamp on it. Okay. So we go home for the night where we’re kind of going to wrap up the trial in the morning. I come back in in the morning and the prosecutor comes up to me and says, hey, t l just FYI, I went and tracked down this business that you presented this, this document for, and we got the actual document and your client changed at the time on the document, and I had him testified to it under oath.
00:54:57:06 – 00:55:25:01
Unknown
Right. Because I didn’t I didn’t know at the time he gave it to me the day of trial. And, so I in that scenario, guys, was a party to committing fraud and committing essentially perjury, by that very act. So what did I do in that situation? What did I have to do ethically? Well, I was in a quandary because do I disclose on the record that my client lied and gave me false information?
00:55:25:16 – 00:55:50:27
Unknown
And that’s there was a tactful way to do this. And what I decided to do with it was I ultimately, before we opened up trial for the day before we brought the jury out, I actually had the judge come out and I said that, I can no longer represent my client due to a conflict that has arisen and due to being a party in presenting evidence that was apparently and allegedly at that point falsified.
00:55:51:02 – 00:56:13:21
Unknown
And I actually had to withdraw from representing the client. And the judge ended up declaring a mistrial, and they retried the case later. And then I also charged him with perjury and falsifying court documents and things like that. But I was freaking out because this was like my third week as a defense attorney or something. And I was like, my law license is on the line, like all that stuff, right?
00:56:13:27 – 00:56:34:15
Unknown
And I was really, really worried. But luckily I did have the support of my boss at the time who actually assisted me in kind of making decisions on how to handle it. And ethically, I was able to handle it the right way and avoid any, any problems there. So but guys, that’s a big one. Don’t ever have your lawyer help you commit a crime without their knowledge.
00:56:34:18 – 00:56:55:08
Unknown
Especially because if you have they have knowledge, they’re not going to help you. But if they don’t and you trick them into it somehow and you do it kind of last minute on the day of trial, while you’re sitting there in the courtroom, you’re going to find yourself probably sitting with additional charges coming down the pipe, plus a now a judge and a Da who are really, really upset with you for what you did and you’re getting retried.
00:56:55:08 – 00:57:20:03
Unknown
So these are the types of that’s an example of kind of how as lawyers, we can’t be used as, you know, tools to commit crimes. You know, against the court or against, you know, the public. So, all right, I want to move on to when conflicts of interest come up. Okay. So this this happens sometimes when we have, you know, situations where two people are charged with committing the same crime, right?
00:57:20:09 – 00:57:56:09
Unknown
Or one’s a victim and one’s a defendant, and sometimes with some frequency, they actually come in and they both want to be represented by us. So how do we handle that and what are our rules about that? Justin, I’m going to come back to you for that. Yep. So basically what the rule states is that a lawyer cannot represent a person if that person’s interest would be directly adverse to another client, or if there is a significant risk that the represent representation would limit the attorneys responsibilities to another client, former client, etc..
00:57:56:19 – 00:58:18:13
Unknown
And I’ve actually had this come up a few times and we’ve just discussed this with respect to, like our dependency stuff, where you’ve been involved already in a number of cases, I’d say 3 or 4 that have come to me that, the chambers has asked to appoint me to, you know, a father or mother or a child.
00:58:18:27 – 00:58:44:22
Unknown
And we’ve kind of discussed that in that we don’t want to get into those situations if we can avoid them just to avoid any potential conflicts of interest. And there was another one where a potential client had reached out that I spoke with a few times, and they were actually coming in for an official consult. And it turns out, I think, that you had represented the victim or a business or something.
00:58:44:24 – 00:59:14:22
Unknown
Yeah. So, you know, that was directly adverse and some, you know, conflicts can be waived. But then there are also conflicts that cannot be waived. Right. And so I think a good example, I kind of want to unpack a few examples here and see what your guys thoughts are on it. So like an obvious one and one I actually see with some frequency is usually it’s like a drug case where there’s drugs in a car, the car gets pulled over there, say there’s just for sake of easiness here, there’s two people involved.
00:59:14:24 – 00:59:34:28
Unknown
Yeah, right. They’re both charged with the same possession of the drugs or possession with intent to distribute the drugs, or even just a. I had about a year or two ago, I had two brothers who were both charged with possession with intent to deliver drugs. They were kind of running a little operation together. And it was clearly a potential conflict.
00:59:35:00 – 00:59:56:21
Unknown
Right. But it’s not always a conflict, because sometimes if you’re if you’re not pointing the finger at each other. Right. Like, if I’m not saying he did it, I didn’t do anything or, you know, you’re saying I did. That might not be a conflict, because if one of us or both of us are kind of saying, hey, you know, we want you to represent me just then, we’re both kind of in this together.
00:59:56:21 – 01:00:15:27
Unknown
We both did this. We’re not blaming each other. Can you help us get a good result? And there are some limited facets where we could still do that. You know, we could still represent both of them. Yeah, but the case could develop and things could happen where we might have to ultimately withdrawal. And that’s also why we put these things in writing to if we’re going to waive a conflict or something like that.
01:00:15:28 – 01:00:30:26
Unknown
Absolutely. So tell me a little bit about what happens when you are presented with a conflict. But you have, say, two people that they really want you to represent each of them. Like how do you kind of analyze that to determine a can you do it? And if you are going to do it, be how you do it?
01:00:31:00 – 01:01:09:22
Unknown
Yeah. So, obviously the attorney has to reasonably believe that they can provide competent representation to each client. The representation is not prohibited by law. Right. The representation does not involve a claim by one client against the other. So essentially pointing the finger at each other. And each client must give consent. An example that I thought of and I don’t know if it was you or another former attorney who worked here, but I was in the DA’s office, and I had a case where essentially it was like a neighbor dispute and a husband and a wife were charged.
01:01:09:25 – 01:01:30:18
Unknown
And then the other side was also charged. Maybe it wasn’t you, but either way, somebody was representing both the husband and the wife on one side of that dispute. Because, again, they weren’t it was, it was like harassment or something like that. And they weren’t pointing the finger at each other. They both, both basically were like, you know, we’re not guilty of this.
01:01:30:26 – 01:01:57:13
Unknown
It was the other guy. Yeah. You know, we’re kind of unified in our defense, right? Either, like, help get us each the best deal. We’re not going to point the finger at each other or. Hey, we we disagree. We didn’t do this. Yeah. Help fight this for both of us. Yeah. You know, and I think, like you said, you know, in, in those situations where they’re really not adverse to each other, if they sign off on it and, you know, you don’t see, foresee, the position changing in the future.
01:01:57:25 – 01:02:14:21
Unknown
I think it would be all right to do that. I, I would generally try to avoid those types of situations. Just because, again, you never know what can happen down the road and say you get all the way to, you know, potentially resolving the case. And then on the day the plea, one of them can’t get through it and everything changes.
01:02:15:04 – 01:02:40:25
Unknown
Then you just, you know, spent six, eight, 12 months working on a case for two people that now you’re ultimately going to have to withdraw from one of them. Start from square one. I would I try to avoid that if I, if if at all possible. Yeah. And I when I do this first of all, if I agree to do this before I agree to do it, I am very, very particular in the conversation that I have with these people.
01:02:40:26 – 01:02:57:19
Unknown
Right. And I want to know what their goals are. And I want to know how aligned or misaligned are they in those goals. Because if there is even a squeak of misalignment there, I usually say, hey, I got a great guy buddy down the street. Does this type of law too. And you know, he’ll help you out and I’ll refer you directly.
01:02:57:19 – 01:03:19:14
Unknown
I’ll call him, we’ll talk it through and we can kind of partner up in this too. Yeah. But in the situations I have done it, I mean, first of all, they’re fully aligned in the defense. I don’t even see the squeak of light that could possibly say, okay, this could go south. Yeah. You know, and it still could, even though I might not foresee it, but I feel pretty confident it won’t.
01:03:19:15 – 01:03:35:08
Unknown
You know, and doing this for a while, you kind of know the nature of how cases play out. Yeah. So you kind of know, like where those mishaps or road bumps can come up. So I kind of play it out in my mind and see it could have come up here. Could there be some issues down the road in certain procedural, you know, plays that we might need to make?
01:03:35:13 – 01:03:51:27
Unknown
But if you’re fully aligned and I don’t see any, you know, problems with it. The second thing and you absolutely got to do this, you got to put it all in writing. Yeah. And you got to essentially say we are agreeing to be represented by you. We don’t we don’t currently believe there are any conflicts with the representation.
01:03:52:12 – 01:04:11:08
Unknown
Or with our wishes. You know, and I also put in there that if that would occur and it’s identified by either the attorney or the client at a later point, that both parties have the full right to disengage in the relationship and then be referred elsewhere. Yeah, at that point. So I think that’s a good way to protect it.
01:04:11:20 – 01:04:28:09
Unknown
But I do kind of agree with your basal approach to it and that like, it’s usually a good idea just not to do it. Yeah, because it can get messy. But every once in a while, like, I just, I really feel it’ll work and I will want to help these people. Yeah. So I occasionally will agree to do it, but it’s a little risky.
01:04:28:10 – 01:04:49:27
Unknown
Yeah. I had a guy recently that retained me for, a couple of cases, and one of them involved, a significant other. And when I had handled one of the cases for him. Met, you know, his significant other and, we had talked about, you know, the potential for me representing both of them in the case.
01:04:50:02 – 01:05:11:03
Unknown
And I didn’t really foresee an issue down the road. But like I said, I, I just aired on the side of caution and was like, hey, basically, like you said, I, I know a guy, a couple guys. You know, I’ll, I’ll send you a referral. Because just the nature of the case and what it was, even though I didn’t think they were going to point the finger at each other.
01:05:11:06 – 01:05:33:20
Unknown
To me, it just wasn’t worth the hassle of essentially starting from square one. On the other case, when we had already kind of worked his out. And I thought that alone could potentially present a conflict in the sense of basically had his case worked out. Now we’re going to go deal with this other case. I don’t know anything about, you know, the other person’s criminal history.
01:05:33:20 – 01:05:51:15
Unknown
I don’t know if their guidelines are going to be the same. If they’re not, could that potentially create, again, some type of issue there. So I just like I said, I referred it out and it ended up working out. You know, they got a decent deal done with the other attorney. And I didn’t have to worry about any type of conflict.
01:05:51:16 – 01:06:08:09
Unknown
Yeah. Yeah. And the one that you mentioned with which you and I had where we got a call from the guy to represent him on the case and, where I actually had previously, a while ago represented a victim in that very case. In the same case, when it first came through, I didn’t realize it was even the same guy.
01:06:08:13 – 01:06:24:02
Unknown
Like, it had been like a year since I had even been involved in the case, but it was apparently still going on. I guess they Wyatt’s relationship with his prior attorney kind of fell apart, and he was looking for other counsel. Yeah. And, he called us and I sent it over to you, and you called him, and I think even.
01:06:24:04 – 01:06:42:19
Unknown
Did you meet with him or so? I didn’t actually. How did we figure out that there was. So basically, yeah, what had happened was so he had a friend that was an attorney out in like, Pittsburgh. And, I forget the guy’s name. I have to actually look him up because, we spent quite a bit of time on the phone just talking about it because the guy was still represented.
01:06:43:00 – 01:07:00:07
Unknown
So his friend, who was an attorney, had reached out to to us. To see if we could help him out. And I spoke to him at length and we set a meeting, and, I honestly don’t remember exactly how it came up. I think I was, you know, I remember it, actually. We were we were talking about the case.
01:07:00:08 – 01:07:12:21
Unknown
Yeah. You came to me, and we were like. We were kind of like, beating around the facts a little bit. And what we could do defense wise. And I was like, damn, this sounds familiar. Like. And I’m thinking about it. And we looked it up, and then I put two and two together and I was like, wait, I think I represented the victim on that.
01:07:12:22 – 01:07:33:26
Unknown
Yeah. And the the victim was part of, we’ll say, a business. Yeah. And I think it was through the business that they got in contact with you because it had to deal with, like, the, like being around the property of the business. Yeah. It did. So what I actually did in that scenario, I mean, we had kind of come to the conclusion, I think, where we could not represent the individual did.
01:07:33:27 – 01:07:52:28
Unknown
But I still just because of my prior client, out of abundance of caution, I called my prior clients who I hadn’t talked to in like a year. Yeah. And I was like, hey, I just wanted to let you know that this guy reached out to us. We didn’t actually, like, really take it anywhere, but we did talk to him a little bit before we realized that it involved this case.
01:07:52:28 – 01:08:13:06
Unknown
We’re not going to take it. I’m going to refer it out, but I did. I did think it was professionally important to at least just disclose that, that that would happen. And I think if, if they had, since it wasn’t going to be you and it was going to be me, I wasn’t here at the time. I think we had discussed there is could I be like bifurcated away from it, but the client just wasn’t comfortable with that.
01:08:13:07 – 01:08:34:12
Unknown
So we just yeah ultimately. Yeah. Referred it out. But yeah that I couldn’t remember exactly how it came up. But now we were sitting in your office. Well, it was actually come full circle on that. I was walking out of the courthouse the other day, and the attorney that we referred that to, who’s a friend of ours, walked up to me and he’s like, hey, I’m going into court today for a, a case that you’re involved in.
01:08:34:12 – 01:08:47:06
Unknown
I’m like, I’m like, what case is that? And why am I not there, you know? And he told me who it was and I was like, oh yeah, that’s right. We actually I was like, we sent that to you. He’s like, yeah, thanks. And he ended up following up with me and they, they worked it out and got a good result.
01:08:47:08 – 01:09:02:00
Unknown
Yeah, yeah, it was good. I think it was definitely workable. But like you said, when you reached out and, you know, if if the former client had said, you know, hey, I don’t care, you know, I’m not really involved with the case anymore. You know, they’re working it out. Whatever. Maybe, maybe. But again, Aaron, on the side of caution and.
01:09:02:00 – 01:09:17:13
Unknown
Right. The fact that they weren’t really comfortable with. Yeah, yeah. Because I know we were kind of like, we both felt like. I feel like we can fix this. Yeah, but we also felt a duty to to to the other side, to the victim. So we ultimately decided not to. But yeah, that was a good one I appreciate that.
01:09:18:07 – 01:09:38:21
Unknown
All right, I want to Tim, I want to pop back over to you here. I want to talk about just kind of some special discussion topic ideas here of some things that could come up. So we have obviously represent clients a lot of times who had met that they are guilty to us but then maintain their innocence as it relates to the court.
01:09:39:07 – 01:09:55:15
Unknown
And as it relates to the prosecution and how they want us to defend their case. Right. Because we frequently ask our clients to tell us the truth. Tell us what happened. We’re only as good as what we know. And I don’t want to get backdoor later because I didn’t know something. So tell me the truth. Tell me what happened.
01:09:55:17 – 01:10:19:19
Unknown
And they say what happened. And, you know, we both agree that. Okay, you’ve essentially just told me you’re guilty of this crime. This is all obviously in a private conference room or my office or something like that. But then we strategically decide to maintain innocence on the case for those purposes, because we think maybe there’s a legal defect with the prosecution, or maybe there’s a suppression issue that we want to attack on, like a vehicle stop or something like that.
01:10:20:08 – 01:10:36:15
Unknown
And that frequently comes up. So how do we represent a client who admits to us that they’re guilty of a crime and wants to maintain their innocence for the purposes of their criminal defense? And can we do it? And what what confines do we have to be careful with there? Yeah. And we’ve talked about this in prior episodes.
01:10:36:15 – 01:11:04:08
Unknown
But yeah, I mean, you can represent someone who you believe or know is guilty, but it it does affect what you can do when you’re making arguments for them and how you’re going to advise them to proceed with the case. You know, I can’t I can’t go into court and lie, which means that even though they may have told me something in confidence, I can’t go into court and deliberately mislead about the confidential facts that I know.
01:11:04:10 – 01:11:38:12
Unknown
So in order to represent someone who we know or suspect is guilty, we have to. We have to just stick to the law and the facts that are presented in court and argue on those things. But yeah, we can do it. But the issue that we run into is can the client accept that that’s kind of the term of the representation, because if they want you to go in there and say the opposite of everything they’ve told you, that poses an ethical problem, and if they’re going to force you into doing something that is unethical, the rules do allow you to withdraw.
01:11:38:14 – 01:11:59:06
Unknown
If you if they’re forcing you into taking actions that you don’t agree with, and they’re forcing you to kind of be dishonest in a way that that is more than just protecting confidential information, then. Yeah, you at that point, you’re not going to be able to effectively represent them anymore, and you’re going to probably have to withdraw from the case.
01:11:59:07 – 01:12:25:01
Unknown
Yeah. So what happens if the client says something to the attorney in confidence? That kind of undermines the defense. Like during the representation. What do we do if the clients privately tells us something that we know is going to strategically undermine the defense that we are currently or maybe even actively presenting, say, in trial or in a hearing or something like that?
01:12:25:03 – 01:12:45:14
Unknown
Do we have to disclose that? Do we have to change course? Can we tell our client, okay, well, I appreciate that. I’d like to kind of just keep that between us. You know, we don’t have to talk about that. Depends. How do we handle that? It depends. It depends on how it how it undermines the defense. If it undermines the defense in a material way, then the defense has probably got to change.
01:12:45:16 – 01:13:16:20
Unknown
But if it’s something that they are aware of which could come out, which would undermine the defense, then you can make the decision in clients. We’ve had clients that have made the decision where they kind of want to know, is that actually gonna be in play? Like if if they’ve done something like, I did this thing, maybe I did something very similar to this before and that could come out, which will undermine my version of this, and it could make it look like I’ve done this before, and I knew exactly what I was doing.
01:13:16:20 – 01:13:43:01
Unknown
And it may undermine a claim or a defense were asserting here, whether it’s self-defense or whether it’s a mistake of fact or something like that. Those kinds of things, if it’s a hypothetical thing that might come out well, it may not necessarily necessitate a, a change in defense strategy, but everybody has to know that this is the defense we’re raising.
01:13:43:01 – 01:14:05:02
Unknown
And if this kind of testimony is introduced by someone else that it can it could potentially destroy our defense. And so you have to have that conversation with your client. And if the client still wants to proceed, that’s fine. You are kind of rolling the dice a little bit though. And there are times where they’re aware of something that we know from research or communicating with them is inadmissible.
01:14:05:07 – 01:14:28:25
Unknown
And so it’s kind of a non-factor. And so, you know, I’ve told people like, yeah, that could be relevant, but I don’t see that as something that can be introduced in this case. So the strategy that we’ve landed on, I think is a sound strategy, because this thing which could potentially have been used against you or it would be a fact that would cut against our defense, it’s it’s not going to come in.
01:14:28:25 – 01:14:47:14
Unknown
And so it’s not going to be a factor. We’re not going to have to worry about that being something that the jury or the judge hears. And then they’re looking back at us going, well, wait a minute. That contradicts something you said earlier. So it just depends on what it is that that comes out that they’re going to say and how that undermines the defense.
01:14:47:14 – 01:15:20:22
Unknown
Does it totally destroy the defense? Does it make our defense less plausible, or is it something that again, induces us to lie? Those are all kind of different shades of the question. And and depending on which shade it falls into, you’re going to have to make a decision at that point. Either change the strategy because you can’t it can’t be worked through or proceed with the strategy, understanding that there’s a risk that this could undermine it, or proceeding with the strategy, knowing that the law is on our side, and that this is not going to be something that affects the defense.
01:15:20:24 – 01:15:48:03
Unknown
Yeah. And guys, we say this all the time. This is why you tell your lawyer everything. This is why unless we tell you not to. But this is why you tell your lawyer everything and you’re honest because it’s protected. And we don’t want to be caught in a situation where we’re in a hearing or in trial. And this does come up somewhat regularly where because they’re hearing certain testimony, it triggers a memory or something that they had not told you, maybe not on purpose, but they forgot.
01:15:48:06 – 01:16:23:28
Unknown
And now they want you to know this information and that could be pivotal. So this is why, when you’re going to spend your money and your time and your effort to have a good attorney who knows what they’re doing to help you give them all the information you can, because you’re only really helping them by doing that. And again, frankly, by and large, it’s all protected anyway, but it helps us create the right strategy for a defense as opposed to a strategy that might have to change mid trial, which can create sometimes too much chaos and can cause you to possibly lose in good attorneys are going to be kind of they’re going to be
01:16:23:28 – 01:16:57:25
Unknown
sensitive to this stuff. Like I’ve had cases where where someone, even in the very first meeting has said something that I later discover is not true, and it does damage the relationship. It’s not something that can’t be repaired, but it damages the relationship because now it calls into question whether you’ve given me correct information, whether I have landed on the correct strategy for your case, or whether there’s more that’s lurking in the bushes waiting to spring out on me when we are going into court.
01:16:57:28 – 01:17:22:07
Unknown
So, you know, I’ve had I’ve had clients who’ve lied to me about very small things, very insignificant things. But in my mind, even a small lie really is a massive tidal wave. It’s a pebble in the ocean that causes this massive wave. And now I have to sit there and wonder, were they truthful with me about other things we’ve discussed?
01:17:22:09 – 01:17:40:24
Unknown
Even if it was a small thing, if they felt the need to lie to me about a small thing, why did they do that? And can I continue representing them? Because some clients, they will be like, well, you know, I forgot about that or I didn’t remember that or I didn’t know other clients may persist in the lie.
01:17:40:26 – 01:18:02:16
Unknown
And that becomes a problem because again, I mean, if you’re lying to me even about something that’s small or maybe isn’t material to the case and you’re persisting in that lie, it really does make it so that I can’t trust you. And that affects my ability to represent you, because, again, it calls into question whether or not we have all the information we need to represent you effectively.
01:18:02:16 – 01:18:21:08
Unknown
So the bottom line is don’t lie to your attorney. Don’t not even about small things. It’s just not it damages the relationship in a way that I think a lot of clients don’t think about, because they think it’s no big deal, and it’s not something my attorney needs to know. So I’m going to keep it for myself.
01:18:21:10 – 01:18:51:18
Unknown
But all of those things are important, and they are a factor at one stage or another of the proceeding. And if you lie about those things, I think the effect that it has on the attorney is much more pronounced than the effect you think it has as the client. Yeah. And I think part of that too, is, you know, the relationship that we have with our clients is a above all professional relationship, but inherently it is personal, too.
01:18:51:19 – 01:19:09:22
Unknown
I mean, we’re in the trenches with these people, you know, and 90% of what we’re doing for them is based on what they tell us. Yeah. And what we’re fighting for, their freedom. We’re fighting for their family. We’re fighting for their lives, you know? And that’s what makes it deeply personal to. So when you there are no rules about the client lying to you.
01:19:09:22 – 01:19:32:24
Unknown
Right. There isn’t rules of ethics about a client being client, but it does destroy sometimes that trust. And as my dad has told me time and time again, when you lose someone’s trust, you kind of lose everything, and it’s really hard to get it back. And sometimes you can’t. But more times than not, it does create a ripple in that relationship that sometimes is irreparable, you know?
01:19:33:12 – 01:20:02:07
Unknown
And that’s unfortunate. So I do try to be sensitive to those things, because sometimes people do lie to us because what they need to tell us is very embarrassing or awkward. And that’s why they didn’t tell us or they lied about something. I have had situations where I’ve sat in a conference room with somebody, and we both have realized that they are now lying to me, or they did lie to me, and I try to have a personal discussion about that with them privately.
01:20:02:09 – 01:20:18:02
Unknown
And a lot of times we can kind of get to a point where we acknowledge it and we say, okay, this is why it happened, but we’re going to we’re able to move past it. But we we know there’s a line in the sand, right? And there’s a red line that we’ve crossed and we we need to kind of repair that.
01:20:18:06 – 01:20:48:22
Unknown
But I think the ones like you said, Tim, who persist and persist and persist, it becomes absolutely irreparable. And sometimes that’s when you have to withdraw, you know. So. All right. The last thing I want to talk about today, guys, is kind of a modern ethical consideration that we see a lot now, the advent of AI, right. And all spiderweb from AI that comes with that and legal research that lawyers do now on AI and things like that.
01:20:48:24 – 01:21:14:01
Unknown
And what do we need to do to protect ourselves in this world of AI that is so prevalent, not only in the legal practice now, but but also in other facets of our lives that kind of bleed into our practice as attorneys. So I’d like to get your thoughts on that, Justin, to start. But I want everybody to contribute to this because there as far as I know, there are no rules in the rules of criminal procedure that talk about AI specifically.
01:21:14:01 – 01:21:51:28
Unknown
And that might be coming. Yeah, I definitely think it’s coming. Yeah. So I see a lot on LinkedIn especially, just pages I follow, people I follow or whatever. They are connections that are posting opinions, orders and judicial rulings from throughout, like all across the country that are dealing with, sanctions and other things that are imposed on attorneys that essentially use AI to create filings, draft motions, responses, etc..
01:21:52:20 – 01:22:18:14
Unknown
And the issue we’ve seen the most, I would say, is that AI pulls from, you know, millions. I don’t know what a huge number of, of of areas of the internet and whatever it can pull from. And it’s essentially creating false case law or case law that is not real. It’s creating case sites that are not real.
01:22:19:02 – 01:22:30:16
Unknown
And attorneys all across the country are getting in a lot of trouble because of it. I think one of the biggest.
01:22:30:19 – 01:23:04:18
Unknown
I guess, sword I want to use. Just the biggest way to avoid that is if you’re going to use AI for research or to draft a motion or response or something, pull case law. You have to check it. You have to double check it yourself. And I don’t know, at least in Pennsylvania, I don’t think there’s anything. But I do believe there are some states that have started to implement rules, procedures, in different guidelines for attorneys with respect to AI and what they’re using it for.
01:23:04:24 – 01:23:28:14
Unknown
So, I mean, it scares the crap out of me, to be honest. The fact that, you know, again, it’s just creating case cases that aren’t real, case sites that aren’t real. And from what I’ve seen, it does seem that there, you know, meshing a few different things together. It’s hallucinating. Yeah, hallucinating, whatever the term is. Yeah, I don’t know.
01:23:28:19 – 01:23:49:15
Unknown
It freaks me out a little bit. And honestly, I, I wouldn’t trust it. To me, it’s easier to just do the research myself. Well, I put something into, you know, ChatGPT or whatever. Just looking for at least, like, a starting point on something. Sure. Yeah, but, you know, I’m not going to use it to I’m not going to put a case site into ChatGPT and say, write me a summary on this or like a brief, you know what I mean?
01:23:49:15 – 01:24:13:01
Unknown
It just it’s not worth it. Well, and people are hiring us. They’re not hiring the AI. Yeah. So like that’s the other thing is like pride in your work product is, I think something that these attorneys don’t have and they’re discovering the hard way that there are consequences. They’re trying to shortcut it. Yeah. Yeah. And so, you know, like I, I’ve definitely experimented with AI because I think it is a valuable tool.
01:24:13:02 – 01:24:30:18
Unknown
I mean, it is able to do things. It can sometimes give you ideas that you might not otherwise thought of. It can sometimes point you in certain directions that can be useful. And it’s good. Just the analysis portion of it alone is very good because it can help you like you can put in. Here are the things I’m thinking.
01:24:30:20 – 01:24:55:21
Unknown
Tell me the strengths and weaknesses of my argument and so it can help you anticipate because the reality test yourself. Yeah, exactly. I mean, it can function as a check on me and on my mind. Depending on how you use it and if you know the right prompts to give it and, and that kind of stuff. And so I think that what attorneys have done is this is the this is the equivalent of copying someone else’s homework.
01:24:55:27 – 01:25:23:15
Unknown
And, you know, it’s it’s that case where you’re where you copy it from someone who’s wrong. And then every everyone down the line is outed immediately because the wrong thing appears on this person’s brief and that person’s brief and another person’s brief. And you can now know all these people use the same AI, the same incorrect information. Maybe they shared it with each other or whatever, and nobody cared to check.
01:25:23:16 – 01:25:46:14
Unknown
Nobody checked. And the judges will get so upset about that because especially the more hands it passes through, it makes it worse. Yeah, it becomes bad, right? And it almost is like a cancer on the system. It’s bad enough if one attorney didn’t catch it. But if two, three, four, five attorneys didn’t catch it. Yeah. Then the the judge is going to be very upset with everyone.
01:25:46:15 – 01:26:08:19
Unknown
I guess the moral of this is if you’re an attorney, use AI to test yourself, to think of other directions you might not have thought of. Right? But it’s more of a test of your own mind. It’s not. This is the law. This is the rule. Just copy and paste. I can’t do that. There’s no substitute for the oversight that you provide.
01:26:08:20 – 01:26:35:00
Unknown
Right. And then you said it very well. Like the client came to us for our expertise, for us as attorney. They wanted us to represent them. They didn’t go ask, you know, a robot to represent them. And and it’s important to note to that with the whenever there’s a problem, the solution is crafted pretty quickly. And in this case now, I mean, one, if you use AI enough, you know what an AI writing looks like.
01:26:35:02 – 01:27:03:04
Unknown
So I think especially as we all begin to embrace AI and use it more, it is becoming easier for us to recognize AI. And this is happening with images. People have gotten really good at spotting AI fakes and like, I’m still not great at that, but with writing. And I’ve had this conversation with clients where we’re both looking at like a character letter, for example, that somebody wrote, and we’re both the client even is like, I don’t think this person wrote this.
01:27:03:10 – 01:27:27:26
Unknown
And I’m like, yeah, it does look a little bit AI. Yeah. And so like, there are now resources that can be used to put in whatever you’re submitting to. Check if it’s an AI prompt. So like that is being engineered by people who are now the market for it. Yeah. And so now the market has been it has been created for people who are going to create like AI checkers and AI oversight.
01:27:27:26 – 01:27:44:16
Unknown
So like that’s going to happen at some point too. It’s already starting to happen. I mean, you’re kind of in this kind of reminds me of do you remember when Covid happened and we were all using like zoom to do hearings, right. None of us knew how to use it yet. And we were like, you would have like like a cat skin on or something.
01:27:44:16 – 01:27:59:15
Unknown
You couldn’t figure out how to get it off or or you, you couldn’t turn your camera or your mute button on it, like, like stupid stuff like that. And it was obvious, like when you were screwing up, right? It kind of reminds me of this a little bit, because that was new then, and we’re now pretty damn good at it.
01:27:59:21 – 01:28:21:14
Unknown
And we still even use zoom sometimes in hearings. But, I don’t see those mess ups anymore like I used to, and I kind of. Now I feel like we’re in that advent with AI, where we’re seeing all these people that don’t really get the power that it is and don’t get how to use it, or to to use it to advantage their position as opposed to just copying it.
01:28:21:15 – 01:28:37:26
Unknown
Right. And I think what we’re going to find is a couple of years from now, I mean, mark my words, I’m going to predict this. We’re going to be so damn good at it that we’re either going to be able to spot it like clockwork, like every time, or it’s going to be run through systems that are going to check it for us.
01:28:37:27 – 01:28:57:27
Unknown
And I think that’s where we’re headed. Yeah, it’ll be automated. We’re probably both. Right. Yeah. So I also just don’t get why like I’ve put a lot of prompts into AI. Right. And I’ve used AI for things at home, like for chore lists and all kinds of other stuff. It’s it’s a great tool. Anyone who’s saying that AI is not useful doesn’t know AI.
01:28:58:00 – 01:29:20:12
Unknown
They like they haven’t used it. It has a place. Oh yeah. But the thing is, like, I would never submit something AI did, especially calling it my own work. Yeah, because you got as a lawyer, you’re signing that get that to me is just so crazy that that like I would I take pride in writing my own motions and putting thought into them.
01:29:20:12 – 01:29:45:16
Unknown
And actually, because I kind of like writing, but like I does, I know that’s why it’s him. That’s why you’ve written me some excellent motions, I love it. I don’t like the idea of just farming that out to AI and being like, hey, I hear the AI wrote this that like to me, I don’t get that. I don’t know why an attorney would just put something into AI and be like, write this motion and then print it out, sign it and submit it to court because we have Sinai.
01:29:45:18 – 01:30:00:10
Unknown
I mean, your bar number is on it. You were signing it as the lawyer. Your bar numbers on the line, like your license is on the line like these. This is why people are actually getting in trouble for the stuff that I do with AI is like, it’s for my eyes only. Yeah, you know what I mean? Like, it’s akin to notes, right?
01:30:00:12 – 01:30:24:18
Unknown
And the way that I, the way that I treat AI is it’s an extension of my note taking, which would be something that is, it exists outside of the client file because it’s my impressions of it. And I’m putting things into AI to test my impressions here. Here’s here’s the strengths and weaknesses of what I’m saying. And then I can go back and I can make notes on what the AI is telling me.
01:30:24:18 – 01:30:43:15
Unknown
I can change certain wording, or I can change the argument and you can use it for research. But to be honest with you, a lot of the open source AI stuff, if it’s not meant for legal research, it’s probably not great because it’s akin to doing legal research on Google. Yeah, like you wouldn’t do that. You would. You would want legal software.
01:30:43:16 – 01:31:00:16
Unknown
And I kind of feel like the stuff on there that is wrong. Like that’s good. Like, serves you right. Like those phantoms should be there because that’s how people tell that you’re not really doing legal. You’re phoning it in. Yeah, you’re phoning it in. I think to like as far as the research thing goes, like you really can’t beat.
01:31:00:19 – 01:31:18:00
Unknown
Well, we used to use books, actually, I think my first year of law school microfilm was talked about, the legal writing. We had to, like, look in books and everything. And I know that’s completely gone at this point. But like Lexis, Westlaw, all of those like the key sites, law school, they don’t have books anymore. No.
01:31:18:01 – 01:31:35:06
Unknown
When we were at Widener, they were like, they had like a section of the library that was like a stack of books, like they were just like it was stuff that was not so used anymore. Maybe this just sells you. I’m doing this too long. But. So people in law school now don’t have like, textbooks. They have text textbooks I’m talking about, like, for legal research.
01:31:35:07 – 01:31:53:25
Unknown
Yeah. Like you have to go and pull nine books. Like, we have all these books in there. Yeah, well, yeah, we’d have to find the key site. These are a research tool like LexisNexis West. Yeah, but my first year of law school for legal writing, one or whatever it’s called, there was like part of a class or two classes where we actually went into the library and, like, did it with the books.
01:31:53:25 – 01:32:14:01
Unknown
I’m like, oh, this is so I don’t think any fishing. Right, right, right. Even back then. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But do you ever have to do, like microfilm? I’ve only. Yeah, but not for legal stuff. I did microfilm a little bit, like with my parents. Like looking up old newspaper articles and stuff. My dad’s really into, like, genealogy and history, and we would sometimes go to the library.
01:32:14:01 – 01:32:25:20
Unknown
I remember as, like, a younger person and, like, look at microfilm, like newspaper articles. And because, I mean, there are attorneys before us where it was like that was how they had to do. Yeah. And maybe that’s why we did it, because that’s what he knew. I don’t know, but like, I was a kid at the time. So.
01:32:25:21 – 01:32:46:28
Unknown
Yeah. So I mean, it’s just funny the research has changed. But I’ve talked about this before. I mean, even like with Lexus and some of the other like Westlaw, they have like a syllabus before case laws, like opinions. And that syllabus is written and edited by someone else. It’s not part of the opinion. And so like I’ve seen cases like a summary.
01:32:47:00 – 01:33:09:04
Unknown
Yeah, I’ve seen cases where the summary says something that is the exact opposite of the ruling that the court actually came to in the opinion. Nice. And so if you’re the kind so like this has already been kind of an issue where like if you’re the kind of attorney who’s legal research is, you pull up a case and you read the syllabus and you scan that and you’re like, oh, I’m gonna I’m gonna cite this case in court.
01:33:09:09 – 01:33:29:10
Unknown
You were already on shaky ground because some of the summaries are wrong and they have a they have a place where you can go to to notify Lexus or Westlaw that the syllabus is incorrect, and then you can propose edits and all that kind of stuff. But people are doing that now with AI, it’s probably submitted so many of those to I think I’ve only submitted one one.
01:33:29:13 – 01:33:48:01
Unknown
Oh, used to come in my office all the time, be like, what do you think about this case? And then he’d be like, it was complete. The summary was completely wrong. The key sites are that’s one one more than I submitted, so it may be more than I don’t remember. There’s one that I remember, but you know, and that’s and the other thing about AI, which is a really big they’re gonna they’re gonna hire you.
01:33:48:02 – 01:34:13:24
Unknown
You can’t I’m not letting them post you from now. That’s now that’s like a job you take, like at the end of your career. That’s true. Yeah. Sitting at a desk somewhere. Yeah, exactly. Just reading stuff, which I like writing, but that would be. That’d be a lot. The the other thing about AI is confidentiality. Like, if you’re putting stuff into AI, there is, I think, a question of where does that information go and where is it stored and is it subject to attack.
01:34:13:26 – 01:34:31:21
Unknown
So that’s something that I think is a little bit more. That’s a little bit of a question because like I’ve even put in like a picture for example into AI, like a picture in evidence. Right. Let’s say like one, one case, I did this, it was like one of those typical like, like a drug and gun case.
01:34:31:24 – 01:34:55:13
Unknown
And it was like one of those cop brag photos where they have everything laid out and and everything there. And I put it in and I asked the a question along the lines of, what in this photo speaks to intent to deliver controlled substances, just to see what it would say, just to test it. Right. But and so like, that’s okay because it’s not really like a confidential thing.
01:34:55:14 – 01:35:19:12
Unknown
Like there’s no confidential anything. Yeah. Not revealing. But if you’re putting in like Social Security numbers and stuff like that, now you’ve got a problem. And even even what I did, like, you have to be careful with that, because if you’re putting in confidential information, stuff that that would not that would be sensitive information once it leaves you and it goes into the AI, you’re the one that’s kind of responsible for it.
01:35:19:12 – 01:35:36:15
Unknown
So if the AI gets hacked and then that information gets published everywhere, well, now you have to answer to client, to a client why their identity got stolen from a hack in chat or a South Park episode with the cloud. Yeah. Everything’s in the cloud. We’ve we’ve mentioned that reference. Levi. Throw it in the episode. We already did it.
01:35:36:16 – 01:36:09:07
Unknown
Oh, we did, we did okay before, but nothing beats the Uncle Rico one. Yeah, yeah. The, the other thing with like, electronic messaging because, like, I don’t think we were going to talk too much about that. But I do think it’s worth pointing out, because this was an ethical issue that I encountered recently, is that, the disciplinary board does have an opinion, which I think is from some time ago now, where their opinion is essentially that emails and text messages are not part of the client file typically.
01:36:09:09 – 01:36:39:16
Unknown
Now, if they’re if it’s something that is really, really important to the case, then it is the client’s property. But the reason I bring this up is because in my discussions working through the the ethical issue that I had, it’s it’s apparent to me that this is an area of, of concern for the, the D board. So they are, I think, actively debating the question about whether guidance or a rule should be put out on preservation related to text messages specifically because there’s, I think, a divide that’s emerging.
01:36:39:16 – 01:37:10:10
Unknown
Some people think text messages should not be reachable by the client. Some people think that it is reachable by the client. It should be and it should be in the file and all that stuff. And that could be a problem because again, sometimes you don’t want to see how the sausage is made. And you may not like the, the way that, that attorneys are communicating with opposing counsel or with officers, because you may think that it’s too familiar or you may get the wrong impression from seeing it.
01:37:10:10 – 01:37:29:19
Unknown
And even though and you may forget that that got you a really good result. So that’s, I think, the argument why people think it shouldn’t be included, but people also think that clients have a right to see all that stuff. And so that’s where the debate is. And right now text messages are not included in the rule at all.
01:37:29:21 – 01:37:50:07
Unknown
But I could see that changing in the future, that text messages would potentially be something that clients have a right to look at. And that means if you’re communicating with the text on your personal device, that your personal device could potentially be discoverable in in future actions, which is a huge problem for attorneys, especially in our space, that’d be a huge problem.
01:37:50:09 – 01:38:15:02
Unknown
So just bear that in mind. I have clients asking me all the time if I can text some things, and I straight up am like, no, yeah, don’t do it. Yeah. And that’s a good way to kind of wrap this up to I think sometimes people forget that although we as attorneys need to abide by these rules of ethics, these rules of professional conduct, and they are near and dear to us and our ability to continue practicing and do it well.
01:38:15:04 – 01:38:48:16
Unknown
There is also a, you know, a sector of this practice that we are professionally. Many times either friendly or, maybe advantageously friendly or with opposing parties. Right. And that’s I think that’s probably true across a lot of different professions, you know, competing dentists, competing doctors, you know, businessmen that are maybe adversaries. They still have a level of collegial communication that isn’t always 100% professional and robotic all the time.
01:38:48:18 – 01:39:11:13
Unknown
Right. And that’s why I think some of this stuff is up for debate, because is that really fair to have to turn over? Right, if you ultimately still get to the right result? And a lot of times the reason we do that that way is it is a strategic benefit to our client to have that relationship, to be able to communicate well with that other side and to be at least advantageously friendly with them, you know.
01:39:11:15 – 01:39:29:01
Unknown
Now, does that mean we go into court and we’re we’re buddy, but absolutely not. But we’re talking about outside of the courtroom, like just all the negotiation that happens in the discussion that happens and everything like that. So I just I want people out there to know, like, the sausage isn’t made, like you said to him, the way that you might think it is.
01:39:29:03 – 01:39:56:07
Unknown
But at the end of the day, there are rules to making the sausage right. And we have to follow those rules. And all lawyers do if you want to keep, you know, doing your, your craft. So I hope this is helpful to not only the lawyers out there, our colleagues, but also to people that are clients of lawyers to understand that we have to operate in a certain sandbox, and we have to follow those rules.
01:39:56:07 – 01:40:15:22
Unknown
And why we do things sometimes is because we are bound by these rules. So I appreciate everybody listening to this episode again. I hope this wasn’t a dry episode. It was one we’ve been talking about doing for quite a while. And I wanted to do, because it talks a lot about the inner workings of being an attorney and the rules that we have to follow.
01:40:15:27 – 01:40:35:28
Unknown
So again, guys, this is now we defend here at Kearney Law. Check us out TikTok. Instagram. Spotify and YouTube. Facebook. All that stuff. Keep the questions coming. Keep chatting with us. We’re happy to do it. And the best thing for you guys is it’s all free. There’s no bills coming from interacting with us and having these these questions and these debates.
01:40:36:08 – 01:40:55:03
Unknown
Plus, if any of you have any issues you want to talk to us about that are real and personal to you, and you want to potentially think about being a client here at our law firm, please reach out. We’re happy to talk to anybody about anything. Like we said earlier in this episode, if it’s not in our wheelhouse, we know a guy and we’ll make sure we get you to the best person possible.
01:40:55:09 – 01:40:57:26
Unknown
Thanks again guys. You have a good rest of the week. Take care.